Author: Pietro Oliva
Product: NC200, NC210, NC220, NC230, NC250, NC260, NC450
Affected version: NC200 <= 2.1.8 build 171109, NC210 <= 1.0.9 build 171214,
NC220 <= 1.3.0 build 180105, NC230 <= 1.3.0 build 171205,
NC250 <= 1.3.0 build 171205, NC260 <= 1.5.1 build 190805,
NC450 <= 1.5.0 build 181022
The issue is located in the httpLoginRpm method of the ipcamera binary (handler
method for /login.fcgi), where after successful login, there is no check for
NULL in the return value of httpGetEnv(environment, « HTTP_USER_AGENT »). Shortly
after that, there is a call to strstr(user_agent_string, « Firefox ») and if a
User-Agent header is not specified by the client, httpGetEnv will return NULL,
and a NULL pointer dereference occurs when calling strstr, with consequent crash
of the ipcamera process.
After the crash, the web interface on port 80 will not be available anymore.
An attacker could exploit this issue by just sending a login request with valid
credentials (such as admin or limited user), but without an user-agent HTTP
header. Default credentials can be used to bypass the credentials requirement.
The disassembly of affected code from an NC200 camera is shown below:
0x0047dca0 lw a0, (user_arg)
0x0047dca4 lw a1, (password_arg)
0x0047dca8 lw t9, -sym.swUMMatchPassword(gp)
0x0047dcb0 jalr t9
0x0047dcb8 lw gp, (saved_gp)
0x0047dcbc sw v0, (auth_result)
0x0047dcc0 lw v0, (auth_result)
0x0047dcc8 bnez v0, 0x47de34
0x0047dcd0 sw zero, (arg_54h)
0x0047dcd4 lw a0, (environment)
0x0047dcd8 lw a1, -0x7fe4(gp)
0x0047dce0 addiu a1, a1, -0x7cb0 ; « HTTP_USER_AGENT »
0x0047dce4 lw t9, -sym.httpGetEnv(gp)
0x0047dcec jalr t9
0x0047dcf4 lw gp, (saved_gp)
0x0047dcf8 sw v0, (user_agent_ptr)
0x0047dcfc lw a0, (user_agent_ptr) ; <== This pointer could be NULL
0x0047dd00 lw a1, -0x7fe4(gp)
0x0047dd08 addiu a1, a1, -0x7ca0 ; « Firefox »
0x0047dd0c lw t9, -sym.imp.strstr(gp)
0x0047dd14 jalr t9
2nd December 2019 – Initial vulnerability report for NC200.
4th December 2019 – Vendor confirms vulnerablity but does not start fixing
due to the product being end-of-life.
4th December 2019 – Notified vendor the vulnerability details will be public
and it should be fixed.
6th December 2019 – Thanks for your opinion, we will discuss and write back
7th February 2020 – Notified vendor issue exists on NC450 and possibly all
models in between. Fixed a disclosure deadline in 30 days.
8th February 2020 – Vendor: We will check but please be patient.
18th February 2020 – We failed to reproduce the issue with the provided PoC.
<trying to troubleshoot>
24th February 2020 – Reverse engineered all the firmware images on behalf of
the vendor and notified they were all vulnerable.
2nd March 2020 – Vendor asks to check fixes for NC200.
2nd March 2020 – Confirmed fix. Asked the vendor to do the same on all cameras.
3rd March 2020 – Vendor will check on other cameras, but will take some time.
3rd March 2020 – Asked the vendor to be quick.
9th March 2020 – Notified CVE identifier to vendor, gave extra week to patch.
9th March 2020 – Vendor is testing fix on all models.
13th March 2020 – Vendor asks to confirm fixes.
13th March 2020 – Confirmed fixes and asked the vendor to publish updates.
Disclosure delayed one week to give some time to patch if
the vendor published firmware updates.
29th March 2020 – No updates have been made public by the vendor. Releasing
details to the public after almost 4 months from initial